The Heartbreak Choir is a beautifully performed ensemble piece and a love letter to the connection of local community
The Heartbreak Choir is a relatively new work by playwright Aidan Fennessey, who sadly passed away shortly before the first production started its Melbourne season in 2022. The Auckland Theatre Company production, directed by Lara Macgregor, opened at ASB Waterfront Theatre last week.
Although The Heartbreak Choir is set in Victoria, the setting and situation of the play could just as easily be any rural town in New Zealand. It’s comfortingly recognisable with the dusty local hall, its curtained-off stage, old zip boiler in the partitioned kitchen, the bar heater that glows more than it heats, and a tired piano tucked in one corner. The production design is spot on, as soon as the curtain opened, it felt like being back in one of those halls and there was many a wry chuckle of recognition from the audience.
The community choir and immersion in local small-town politics provide the perfect breeding ground to explore various stories and personalities.
The play opens with a choir split apart by a yet unknown disagreement among its members, with a small group striking out on their own in the chilly hall. It is a play with music not a musical, and although also very comedic, as narratives unfold we’re confronted by darker issues like the suicide of Caroline, one of the choir’s members, and sexual abuse in the Catholic Church. The fallout that is hinted at throughout the first half, has caused a fracture among the choir members.
As a reviewer, I was concerned that the shift in tone might disturb some audience members. On reflection, however, it is how we often deal with complex and tragic events — dancing around them until someone blurts something out, or becomes emotionally overwhelmed. It also reflects what Fennessy was experiencing in his life, as he had terminal cancer when he wrote the play.
According to his wife, author Nove Weetman: “He knew it would be his last, but he was inspired by the choir he’d recently joined and wanted to write a play that wove together community, connection and the power of singing to unite people.”
As a result, his characters feel very real; I have met someone similar to all of them in my life in New Zealand and Australia.
Choirmaster Barbara (Alison Quigan), is a psychologist and potential politician who always strives to do the right thing, but gets very flustered along the way, hence her nickname ‘Care Bear‘.
Mack (Kate Louise Elliott) may be loud, bolshie and prone to embarrassing her daughter, but she is also principled and loyal. Her daughter Savannah (Esmay August) is quiet but determined, trying to forge her own identity. Her story is hinted at but never fully realised, but August brings a strong performance and her beautiful voice to the production.

Totty (Jodie Dorday) is the highly efficient, but emotionally distant organiser who keeps the choir and town on track, but beneath it beats a heart of gold.
Anesu (Munashe Tapfuya) is a heavily pregnant Zimbabwean immigrant waiting on her doctor’s registration while working in the deli. She brought a realness to her character, especially the strong faith and principles that help keep the choir on track when it comes to the crunch.
I thought the casting of Samoan David Fane as Peter the local policeman, grieving husband of Caroline and father of Beau (Levi Kereama) was inspired, as it better reflects the flow of cultures through the Pacific, Australia and New Zealand. He is the emotional core of the piece as he reaches out for connection with the choir and his son Beau.
If there is one criticism, it is that the roles of Savannah and Beau are a little underwritten and I wonder if Fennessy would have boosted those roles if he had lived.
The cast sings beautifully, making me wish there was more music in the piece. According to Musical Director Jason Te Mete, they had the freedom to select songs that suited the actors, while sticking to an Australian song catalogue.
After several weeks of floods and storms in Auckland, it was lovely to feel immersed in the choir’s world for a while. I laughed harder than I have for a long time, and although it has its heartbreak moments, it succeeds in what Fennessy intended – bringing people closer together through the power of music and connection.
The Heartbreak Choir offers plenty of laughs alongside some tears and beautifully performed songs to connect you with a lovable cast of recognisable characters.
I highly recommend you see this production at the ASB Waterfront Theatre until the 4th of March.
Reviewed by Adrienne Kohler.
