The Play That Goes Wrong gives us murder, mayhem, and a total theatrical meltdown
The longest-running comedy in London and a smash-hit Olivier and Tony Award winner, The Play That Goes Wrong has tumbled into Auckland’s ASB Waterfront Theatre. It brought with it a night of raucous laughs and wonderfully choreographed chaos in this hazardous and hilarious whodunit.
As the audience settled in, the Cornley Drama Society prepared to present their latest production, The Murder at Haversham Manor. The mayhem started even before curtain up, with frantic stage crew Trevor (Eds Eramiha) and Annie (Olivia Charalambous) desperately trying to wrangle a missing dog and prepare the ill-fated set.
Once the play began, calamitous comedy erupted. The actors valiantly pushed on despite collapsing sets, missed cues, forgotten lines, and an ever-growing list of injuries. The result was a gloriously ‘gone wrong’ production that was hugely entertaining. These am-dram performers relished their time in the spotlight, and nothing was going to ruin their moment.
The play’s director, Chris (Johnathan Martin), in his role as Inspector Carter, tries to hold the show together. But it’s with the audience that he finally unravels, delivering a wonderfully Fawlty-esque break of the fourth wall, chastising us for our silly laughter and lack of theatre etiquette. Martin’s simmering frustration adds to the farce and proves a comedic highlight.
Robert (Joe Kosky), playing the role of Thomas Colleymoore, delivers every line with exaggerated flair and over-enunciation, a serious actor utterly committed to his craft. His performance is delightfully over-the-top as he rescues falling props, battles through distasteful whisky, and performs feats of strength rarely demanded of an amateur thespian. Kosky’s dedication to the bit adds another layer of absurdity, making him a standout in this comedic ensemble.
Dennis (Tom Hayward) plays Perkins, a hapless butler who battles mispronunciations to the delight of the audience. Clearly younger and less experienced than most of the cast, he gives it his all, earning big laughs as he stumbles earnestly through the mayhem.
Playing the unfortunate corpse, Charles Haversham, is Jonathan (Broadie Masini), who puts on a valiant dead face amid the chaos unravelling around him. His attempts to remain lifeless are entertaining, but when he finally gets his chance in the spotlight, the audience rewarded him with plenty of cheers and applause.
A big crowd pleaser on the night was Max (Sebastiano Pitruzzello), playing Cecil, the deceased’s brother. With joyful over-the-top physicality and a grin that only grows with every laugh he earns, Pitruzzello turns every scene into a chaotic delight.
Sandra’s unexpected rival comes in the form of stage manager Annie (Olivia Charalambous), who’s reluctantly thrust into the spotlight—only to discover she enjoys it far more than anticipated. Her theatrical turn sparks a hilarious power struggle for the limelight.
Sandra (Stephanie Astrid John), playing Florence Colleymoore, channels a quirky, exaggerated parody of the 1920s hysterical woman. Her dramatic delivery is perfectly overblown, and when someone dares to steal her spotlight, we see her mask slip in the funniest of ways.
That someone is stage manager Annie (Olivia Charalambous), who is reluctantly thrust into the role and then enjoys it far more than expected. Her escalating hunger for stage time sparks a hilarious tug-of-war between her and Sandra. Meanwhile, Trevor (Eds Eramiha) becomes a crowd favourite when he’s dragged into the chaos, forced to join the desperate cast in a valiant attempt to keep the sinking ship afloat.
From pratfalls to exposed panties, The Play That Goes Wrong is a fast-paced, cleverly choreographed and charming disaster that delivers big laughs from start to finish. It’s a joyous celebration of things falling apart and the determined but failed attempts to hold it all together. I think we can all relate to that!
Reviewed by Ingrid Grenar
The Play That Goes Wrong is on at the Auckland ASB Waterfront Theatre 14 May – 1 June 2025

