Carl Donnelly – The Classic
Carl Donnelly is making his debut at the 2014 Comedy Festival. Despite previous appearances, this is his first solo show in New Zealand, and he’s a little nervous. But if the warm response he received at last night’s performance is any indication, he shouldn’t be.
Right off the bat, Donnelly announces that he is currently trying to deal with a messy divorce, and the situation informs a lot of his comedy. The differences between men and women is an old, worn out topic when it comes to stand up, but thankfully it’s really just a springboard for Donnelly to do what he does best – tell stories. Generalities are ignored in favour of personal anecdotes, and those expecting joke after joke may be a little surprised by his candor, where much of the evening is made up of tales of his newly single foolishness and dangerous love of crumpets.
If I was a little worried about his tendency to involve the crowd (too shy to get involved, it’s why I critique), it soon becomes obvious that this just allows him with more room to riff. Donnelly forms bits on the fly. Ideas come to him in the middle of one story that can cause several minute tangents. This can result in some moments where the actual punchlines are few, but Donnelly’s storytelling is amusing enough to hold interest.
It makes for a light, easygoing experience, one where you can see the comic process occur right in front of you. If not a joke-a-minute, Donnelly’s free-flowing monologues are wonderfully unpredictable. I’m still not entirely sure how much was preplanned and how much just comes to him throughout the set, but that’s a plus in my book.
See Carl Donnelly at The Classic Saturday 26 April, and from Monday 28 April – 3 May.
Reviewed by Liam Golds
