I AM Auckland Arts Festival Review
I Am, the performance from Lemi Ponifasio and his company Mau, is grand, audacious and memorable. But is it wonderful? Is it breathtaking and shocking and something you’d recommend to everyone you know? Unfortunately – and categorically – it isn’t.
I Am feels like a show whose ambition has taken it to a place so abstract, so highbrow and so self-elevated as to completely lose its audience. It’s fantastic to be ‘genre-defying’ as the Arts Festival proclaims (accurately), but taking away all convention in this instance seems to have left us with a visual theatre piece that’s devoid of soul.
I found it excruciatingly long, at 2 hours (no interval) and there are dozens of lengthy, drawn out scenes where either a single motion or phase is repeated endlessly by the cast without transporting us anywhere special or creating any sort of magic. While there are some beautiful karakia and haunting spoken and chanted episodes, there are too many instances where the cast’s voices are instruments of shouting, moaning and monotony. There is no real interaction between the performers to indicate they are anything other than a line up of bodies on a stage. The soundtrack is less music and more abstract sound, which is fine, but its insistent and violent volume is headache-inducing.
However, there are some beautiful and strong elements to this work that doesn’t fit neatly into a category of ‘dance’, ‘theatre’ or ‘musical’. The staging and sets are huge, dark and ominous, and provide the perfect backdrop to the cast’s monochromatic and sober costumes. The lighting is superb, in particular one scene near the show’s finale where moving light simulating a waterfall over the entire stage and backdrop is spectacularly executed.
The programme tells us that I Am is a reflection on 100 years of war, and that the show explores this theme of conflict through different cultures and influences. And certainly, there is plenty of anguish to behold on stage throughout the performance. But while the incessant violent overtones and drawn-out still silences might be endeavouring to portray these themes, ultimately they left me indifferent and unmoved.
Reviewed by Natalie Ridler
I AM is on at the ASB Theatre for another night on the 8 March.
