Spencer fails to capture the true charisma of Diana
Spencer, by Chilean director Pablo Larrain and starring Kristin Stewart, continues the decades-long exploitation of Princess Diana with yet another movie about the exploitation of Princess Diana.
The challenge for any filmmaker wishing to make Princess Diana their subject is how to bring something new to the story of one of the most well documented and photographed women of the 20th Century. It would be hard to find a moment of Diana’s life that has not been intensely scrutinised, retold and fictionalised in multiple ways – most of them poorly.
The latest in this very long list is Spencer directed by Pablo Larraín, written by Steven Knight, and starring Kirsten Stewart as Diana.
Larrain takes up the challenge with gusto by focusing on three days at Sandringham Estate where the Royal family traditionally gather for their Christmas Holidays. After ten years, Charles’ and Diana’s marriage is clearly terminal and Diane is seeking the courage to leave.
Spencer presents itself as “A fable from a true tragedy” and reviews so far are split as to whether the film is a masterful and haunting psychological drama, or an overwrought melodrama more suited to the Lifetime channel if it wasn’t so depressing.
Unfortunately, I fall into the latter camp, and seldom have I disliked a movie more than Spencer. Generally, I am very forgiving of flaws in movies, and am happy to go along with the filmmaker’s vision and intent, but I admit I blurted out an involuntary “oh ffs” at one of the more ludicrous scenes.
The film contains so many inaccuracies from a historical perspective that it fails as a biopic, and as a work of fiction adds to the substantial body of work exploiting Diana’s life and death.
Larrain and Kristen Stewart have created a caricature of Diana who twitches and mopes her way around Sandringham, moaning about her fate in life against a desaturated colour palette and soundtrack of discordant jazz and strings just in case we don’t get from her sad face that she is unhappy.
Gratingly, Stewart seems to have based her accent on Diana’s voice when delivering speeches and not her natural speaking voice, and it comes over as an extended impersonation rather than a real human talking.
By 1991, Diana had morphed out of her flouncy teenage years into a sleek fashion icon, but the design team seem to have simply plonked an early Diana hairstyle wig on Stewart, ignoring the shorter more sophisticated style Diana was then wearing. It’s also a pity the budget didn’t extend to blue contact lenses for Stewart, as the most striking feature of the princess were her stunning eyes, and ability to convey her mood through a glance.
Weirdly, apart from Charles and a few lines from the Queen, there are virtually no scenes or interactions with any of the royal family members who were meant to be making her life so miserable. Never have I missed Prince Phillip’s acerbic comments so much! Charles is once again reduced to a selfish bumbling idiot, while Timothy Spall, who plays the equerry, Major Gregory, keeps popping up like Hamlet’s Ghost to ensure Diana is toeing the royal line.
Larrain and screenwriter Steven Knight seem to have forgotten the writing adage “show not tell” so sudden jumps are used to skip over significant events, which are then relayed to various staff members by Diana as evidence of the misery of her life. We are told that Charles gave Diana and Camilla identical sets of pearls, rather than seeing her discovery and realisation.
The film is riddled with historical errors and ludicrous situations, like Diana driving on her own to Sandringham in an open convertible Porsche in the middle of an English winter, without her protection team at a time when the IRA was active and a very real threat. Then she gets lost in a county where she grew up and had been travelling back to for the last ten years.
Nonetheless, I can see what Larrain was striving for – a psychological study of a woman trapped in a gilded cage, struggling to find her agency and a way out. But did he have to turn Diana into a raving loon to do that?
A major issue I have with the film is its depiction of Diana’s mental state. It is well-documented that she was struggling with bulimia and depression, largely as a reaction to the lack of care and love she received, but Larrain and Knight decide to ramp this up to full-blown psychosis, with Diana hallucinating about Anne Boleyn and wandering around the corridors of Sandringham like she’s a ghost from The Shining.
By using her as the subject of a fictional piece that takes such liberties with the truth, Spencer relegates Diana yet again to caricature and not an actual human being. Larrain continues to use her life and death as fodder for our entertainment with no real purpose and perpetuates the same voyeurism that ultimately led to her death and created deep trauma for her children.
In fact, Spencer, and virtually every other work about Diana, have never captured the charisma, charm and wicked sense of humour that lay behind her popular appeal. Wrapping the film in the cloak of a work of fiction doesn’t make it any less exploitative and brings nothing new to our understanding of Diana’s life.
Spencer is out nationwide in NZ cinemas now.
Reviewed by Adrienne Kohler.

