Reimagining of Peter Pan blends a dark twist with delightful silliness and fantastical on stage creations
Nightsong and the Auckland Theatre Company’s reimagining of J.M. Barrie’s classic Peter Pan offers an unexpectedly darker twist on the beloved tale, yet masterfully balances the depth with humour, silliness, and delightful surprises throughout the performance.
As we took our seats a live band of mermaids are by the side of the stage, led by Anika Moa waving to the audience before curtain up. Their presence provides the atmospheric musical backdrop throughout the show, seamlessly blending haunting melodies and accompanying the pop-style numbers performed by the actors on stage. While they don’t overpower the narrative, their contributions add a rich emotional dynamic that enhances the theatrical experience.

Carl Bland and Ben Crowder’s adapted story of the Darling children and Peter Pan begins on a poignant note, revealing that their youngest brother has tragically died, casting a shadow of grief over their family. The adults, particularly Mr. Darling (Jennifer Ludlam), grapple with their emotions—pushing them aside to focus on trivial matters, like attending a BBQ on time, while Mrs. Darling (Tupe Lualua) wrestles with her desire to stay home and read the children a bedtime story or go out with her husband.
After they are left alone to sleep, John (Angus Stevens) and Wendy (Nova Moala-knox) are swept away into the enchanting yet tumultuous and mischievous world of Peter Pan (Theo Shakes) and Tinkerbell (Junghwi Jo). Their arrival in Neverland triggers profound changes for both the realm and its inhabitants.
Wendy’s grief is a central theme, powerfully expressed during a haunting solo in the first half of the show, capturing the rawness of her loss. Mr Darling transforms into Captain Hook who leads a band of pirates with a mix of fear and comical violence, often at the expense of hapless props. Ludlam truly relishes in the role of pantomime villain, expertly bridging the connection between the grieving father and the emotionally stunted Captain Hook. Moala-Knox shines as Wendy and delivers the emotional energy needed for the story of the other characters to unfold.

Tess Sullivan as Tiger Lily must be having a blast in her role, as she not only looks fantastic but also embodies the arrogance and authority that a wolf character demands. Shakes captures the playful, unruly essence of Peter Pan, embodying the carefree behaviours and reluctance to grow up that define childhood. Junghwi Jo’s Tinkerbell is delightfully rebellious, her jealousy adding a dangerous edge that culminates in a poignant sacrifice filled with emotion. Andrew Grainger’s portrayal of pirate Smee provides a fantastic counterbalance to Hook’s villainy, fully embracing his bad-boy persona while serving as an excellent sidekick. Together, this talented cast honours and enriches the classic tale, making it a truly engaging experience.
The staging, set, and costumes are all brilliantly crafted, ensuring the magic of Peter Pan is brought to life in vibrant detail. With fairy dust explosions, projections and narration, flying children, and thrilling pirate fight sequences, every moment is filled with visual creativity.
The addition of swimming mermaids and even Roux, the adorable Bernese Mountain dog, playing Nana, adds the cherry on top of an already charming cake. A standout feature of the prop design is the enormous crocodile that ominously meanders onto the stage, its hungry intentions sparking both intrigue and delight among the audience. The clever integration of dynamic elements creates an enchanting atmosphere that perfectly captures the essence of this version of Neverland.
The main set transforms brilliantly from the Darling children’s cozy bedroom to a frosty Neverland, shrouded in white sheets and inhabited by Peter Pan, Tinkerbell, and the Lost Boys. The stage is utilised to its fullest potential, with actors appearing up in the wings of the circle and within the ocean carved out at the front of the stage, allowing for swimming mermaids, a menacing giant crocodile, and allows for bodies to be tossed overboard in dramatic flair. The costumes are beautifully designed, with Tiger Lily’s portrayal as a wolf being a standout.
Of course, no production of Peter Pan would be complete without flying, and the performers seamlessly clip on and off wires to create enchanting effects that elevate the childhood imaginations of the audience.

It is refreshing to see loss and grief portrayed so honestly in a family show, and I truly appreciated the lack of innuendo in their approach to such a sensitive topic. This straightforward handling allows audiences of all ages to engage with the themes meaningfully, creating a space for reflection and conversations. By addressing these complex emotions head-on, the production adds a layer of authenticity often missing from traditional family-friendly productions.
This production of Peter Pan serves as an inventive vessel for exploring the fears associated with the journey from childhood to adulthood, all while being drenched in outrageous fun and absurdity that keeps audiences of all ages entertained. The clever blend of humour, emotion, and whimsical elements creates a captivating experience, reminding us of the challenges of growing up while celebrating the joy of imagination. With its creative staging and dynamic performances, this retelling is both thought-provoking and delightfully entertaining, making it a must-see for families and theatre lovers alike.
Reviewed by Ingrid Grenar.
Photo credit: Andi Crown
